Following Erik ten Hag’s dismissal, I thought I’d rewatch his first game in charge of Manchester United, a 2-1 defeat to Brighton back in August 2022, and the signs were ominous…
Following Erik ten Hag’s dismissal, I thought I’d rewatch his first game in charge of Manchester United, a 2-1 defeat to Brighton back in August 2022, and the signs were ominous… Following Erik ten Hag’s dismissal, I thought I’d rewatch his first game in charge of Manchester United, a 2-1 defeat to Brighton back in August 2022, and the signs were ominous…
So the axe has finally swung for Erik ten Hag and honestly… what in the world took Manchester United so long?
For what seems like forever, the Red Devils have been the punchline of the Premier League: an endless soap opera of squandered millions and broken dreams, where every step forward precedes two steps back. Ten Hag’s reign epitomised this, with infighting, transfer blunders and tactical ineptitude blighting every occasional moment of genuine promise.
With the Dutchman now gone, I decided to revisit his very first game in charge, against Brighton back in 2022, in an attempt to figure out whether the signs of his impending downfall were etched onto the wall from day one.
The game ended in a 2-1 defeat, and looking back, that sweltering August afternoon now carries an ominous weight of foreshadowing. Here’s what stood out to me the most:
Poor decision making
Before a ball had even been kicked, Ten Hag stuck his neck out in terms of team selection. With Edinson Cavani gone, Anthony Martial injured and Cristiano Ronaldo sulking on the bench, he opted for Christian Eriksen in a false nine role – and it inevitably didn’t work.
The Dane, usually a playmaker, looked completely isolated up top, unable to provide the dynamism or pressing intensity needed. Ten Hag adjusted by dropping Eriksen back into midfield in the second half, but by then Brighton had already established control.
His substitutions felt reactive, as if he was working with what he had rather than imposing his style – which brings me onto observation No. 2.
Christian Eriksen started the game at false nine, and barely made an impact
(
Image:
PA)
No clear playing style
The most common criticism levelled at Ten Hag during his United tenure was that his team lacked an identity, and that was glaringly obvious from the get-go against Brighton. The Dutchman arrived with a reputation for high-pressing, possession-based football, and was known as a meticulous tactician.
There were snippets of Ajax-esque dynamism against the Seagulls, but impressive moments were few and far between, highlighting a disconnect between his philosophy and the team’s readiness to execute it effectively. United tried to build from the back, but every attempt to push forward looked tentative.
The players seemed to struggle with the quick passing sequences and intricate movements Ten Hag demanded, and against a team as well-drilled as Brighton, they were punished for it. Frequent overturns meant United kept losing their shape, and amidst the chaos the players seemed all too eager to abandon their manager’s instructions – much to Ten Hag’s chagrin.
United lacked cohesion and organisation against Brighton, which said a lot
Timid demeanour
When stepping out onto the Old Trafford turf for the very first time, making a good impression is paramount. For the first 30 minutes of the game, Ten Hag looked the part. Dressed in an understated suit, he prowled his technical area like a bloodhound on a scent trail.
There was a restless energy about him – a welcome sight given the mundanity of predecessors Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and Ralf Rangnick’s touchline antics. He was constantly gesturing, crouching and barking orders, fixating on every mistake and missed opportunity like he was watching a tiny piece of a complex puzzle falling off a table.
But after Brighton’s double salvo before half time, everything changed. As the game slipped away, Ten Hag’s constructive frustration morphed into something more subdued, and far less confident. Suddenly, every misplaced pass or defensive lapse elicited a grimace or a sharp intake of breath.
Ten Hag cut a timid figure on the touchline after United lost their grip in the tie
He was clearly a man full of ideas, but one who was vulnerable to setbacks, and the early cracks were telling. It hadn’t taken much for Ten Hag’s tactical plan to go up in smoke, and when it did, he didn’t really know how to rectify it, nor did he act like a man who did.
Whether he was doomed from the start, or if the United job truly is the most poisoned of chalices is anyone’s guess. But one thing’s for certain: that opening defeat to Brighton was more than just a disappointing start; it was a harbinger of the tumultuous couple of years ahead.
The haunting echoes of that game, as well as the 4-0 defeat to Brentford the following week, never truly dissipated, reminding everyone that sometimes the first step can define the entire journey, for better or worse.
Join our new WhatsApp community and receive your daily dose of Mirror Football content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don’t like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you’re curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
Mirror – Sport