Why Courtois, Lunin dilemma is Ancelotti’s biggest Champions League headache

by | May 28, 2024 | Blog

Carlo Ancelotti will have Real Madrid ready for Saturday’s Champions League final, but he’ll need to deliver some tough news about who’s starting in goal, and getting that wrong could be critical.

​Carlo Ancelotti will have Real Madrid ready for Saturday’s Champions League final, but he’ll need to deliver some tough news about who’s starting in goal, and getting that wrong could be critical. Carlo Ancelotti will have Real Madrid ready for Saturday’s Champions League final, but he’ll need to deliver some tough news about who’s starting in goal, and getting that wrong could be critical.   

Courtois, left, has returned to fitness and is the natural choice to start for Real Madrid in the Champions League final. However, it’s vital that Lunin, right, is ready just in case. THOMAS COEX/AFP via Getty Images

For Madridistas, the most wonderful thing about Carlo Ancelotti is the fact that he keeps on winning trophies for their club. For the rest of us, it’s a happy bonus that the sage Italian is blessed with lovely, well-judged dry wit and humour. It’s a total pleasure having him in Spain.

The latest example of his geniality was on the putative debate about whether Thibaut Courtois, out all season with ACL and meniscus injuries — though the world’s No. 1 goalkeeper, in Ancelotti’s view — or Andriy Lunin, genuinely heroic against RB Leipzig and Manchester City and now a LaLiga champion, should start on Saturday at Wembley against Borussia Dortmund.

Ancelotti joked: “I love this kind of external debate — particularly on weeks like this when I don’t have much to do,” he said with a grin. “So if I told you who’s starting, then I’d miss out on listening to the next few days of fun debate because that would be it over already!

“It’s no big deal: one of them plays and the other’s on the bench. Look … it’s actually a tough decision because Lunin deserves to play for lots of reasons as does Courtois, because he’s the best in the world.”

Gentle, good fun, in which he punctures the stress with a fun answer: That’s typical Ancelotti, though this is actually an important issue.

Stream on ESPN+: LaLiga, Bundesliga, more (U.S.)

Spoiler alert: Unless something unfortunate and unpredictable happens between now and kick-off at Wembley Stadium on Saturday, it’ll be the big Belgian, who initially thought he was going to be a professional volleyball player until his early teens, who’ll start in goal for Spain’s new champions. For those obsessed by guessing the XI, whether for fun or bragging rights, because it’s professionally important for those who reckon it gives an edge when it comes to having a little wager on the likely match outcome, that’s the punctuation point on the story. An end in itself.

For everyone else, most particularly the Italian, the Belgian and the Ukrainian, the starting lineup is only the beginning.

I think there’s a general perception that Madrid, by hook or by crook, are almost sure to win this final. I gently favour that idea, but this column is meant to quash the concept that Los Blancos‘ record in UEFA finals — they’ve not lost a Champions League final in 43 years and are undefeated in any UEFA knockout final since defeat vs. Aberdeen in the Cup Winners Cup of 1983 — is something they’ve achieved “just because they are Madrid.”

And so Courtois will start, but let’s admit one thing: It’s not a guarantee that this will automatically be “his” evening.

Yes, Courtois is a behemoth amongst goalkeepers: Ancelotti is, in my opinion, justified in saying he’s the very best. Or at least when he’s fully fit and sharp. The Belgian missed about 95% of the season and while his return to match duty hasgi been both successful and impressive, I’d draw your attention to another ACL injury sufferer in the Madrid squad: Éder Militão.

Editor’s Picks

2 Related

The centre-half returned to the line-up at the beginning of April, looking fully fit and soon becoming a very strong candidate to start against Dortmund. Then, as is often the case for long-term injury returners, his slow, steady return suddenly hit the buffers at Villarreal, in a match where he looked rusty, indecisive and in need of four or five more demanding matches in order to be back to his best.

The Brazilian was fine, showing signs of being a model recovery where everything was going nicely … and then he wasn’t, and they weren’t. Going from 4-1 up at Villarreal and then, in the blink of an eye, being torn apart by a team in yellow to draw 4-4. That simply can’t be allowed on Saturday.

Maybe what happened to Militao won’t happen to Courtois, but it could, and Ancelotti knows this. The ACL injury used to devastate, and indeed end, many top level careers. It doesn’t have the same effect in the modern era, but it remains a beast of a damage to do to your knee. I hope and pray that neither his knee ligaments nor, more pertinently, Courtois’ sharpness, concentration, form and confidence afflict him in what is only his third Champions League final and an opportunity to win his second medal.

Nevertheless, the key takeaway is that Ancelotti needs to use another of his great skills: the ability to be the “player whisperer.”

play1:12

Carlo Ancelotti reveals his pre-UCL final routine

Real Madrid boss Carlo Ancelotti reveals his pre-Champions League final meal preparation in the lead-up to the game against Borussia Dortmund.

Lunin needs to be told, at the right time, what he already intuits: that his brilliance in the competition this season is only going to win him a space on the bench. It will be a bitter blow, even if expected, but from there the Ukrainian needs to be kept in the right frame of mind. He needs to be kept believing that it’s imperative he remains ready. Not in some patronising “I was born ready, boss!’ thumbs-up manner, either, but really, genuinely 100% at the races and entering the Wembley combat zone with the mindset that it still might quite easily fall to him to win the trophy.

Some examples.

Remember Madrid’s “Novena” (or ninth trophy win)? The 2002 Hampden final which is recalled almost exclusively for Zinedine Zidane’s all-time great volleyed winner?

Cesar Sanchez started that game for Vincente Del Bosque’s side, only to injure himself and come off early. In came young Iker Casillas to produce what Marca this week called “three miracle saves in order to preserve a work-of-art-goal.” At the time, Casillas was disappointed, but he was also ready. both in terms of his mindset and performance. Even if by the time César went off, Casillas wasn’t ready with his keeper-jersey — he delayed play because he insisted on cutting most of the sleeves off with first-aid nail scissors before coming on, because he was so superstitious.

Think about the 2018 Madrid triumph in Kyiv. Liverpool lost Mo Salah to injury after half an hour and took forever to look like they believed they could cope without him. Gareth Bale, genuinely furious to have been benched, came on in the 61st minute and less than two minutes later, was sufficiently “ready” to produce a wonder-goal that might be the equal of Zidane’s at Hampden in terms of beauty, difficulty and impact.

STREAM ESPN FC DAILY ON ESPN+

Dan Thomas is joined by Craig Burley, Shaka Hislop and others to bring you the latest highlights and debate the biggest storylines. Stream on ESPN+ (U.S. only).

These injury/bench/mentality moments often make huge differences in big, pressure-soaked finals. How well-prepared a disappointed, disaffected player is, despite being dropped, can often make a gigantic impact.

The details are for another column, perhaps, but Xavi Hernández always says that were it not for Andres Iniesta coming on at half time against 10-man Arsenal in the Paris final of 2006 then Barcelona were going to lose a match that they snuck 2-1 in the end. Nor is it wholly unheard of for Courtois to need replacing: I was at the 2019 Champions League match against Club Brugge at the Bernabeu when the Belgians went 2-0 up and the Belgian went off, sick, at half time.

Just as an anecdotal sidebar, Wembley isn’t by any stretch of the imagination a talismanic place for either Madrid or Courtois. Pretty surprisingly, Los Blancos have only ever played there once — losing to Spurs, who were temporary tenants at the HQ of English football in 2017 — and Courtois has suffered far more disappointments than triumphs at Wembley. He lost two Community Shields with Chelsea, missing a penalty in the shootout the second time, was dropped for the 2015 League Cup final having played both legs of the sem final, and lost the 2017 FA Cup Final.

The counter arguments are winning at Spurs in the league when they were lodgers at Wembley and, with Toni Rüdiger, winning the 2018 FA Cup final.

This is all my way of saying: Ancelotti is a fun guy to report on, he will pick Courtois to start against Dortmund, but it will also need to keep Andriy Lunin’s spirits up and intensity levels high. The Ukrainian has a case to argue that he’s as important as any Madrid player in reaching the final, but still has a possibility that he could be as important as anyone in winning it.

Terms of UsePrivacy PolicyYour US State Privacy RightsChildren’s Online Privacy PolicyInterest-Based AdsAbout Nielsen MeasurementDo Not Sell or Share My Personal InformationContact UsDisney Ad Sales SiteWork for ESPNCorrections

ESPN BET is owned and operated by PENN Entertainment, Inc. and its subsidiaries (‘PENN’). ESPN BET is available in states where PENN is licensed to offer sports wagering. Must be 21+ to wager. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Copyright: © 2024 ESPN Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved.

 

Trending News

Galaxy hit 6 to rout Loons; Sounders next in West​​

Galaxy hit 6 to rout Loons; Sounders next in West​​

Gabriel Pec, Joseph Paintsil and Dejan Joveljic each scored twice — with one goal in each half — and the LA Galaxy earned a 6-2 victory over visiting Minnesota United FC in Sunday’s Western Conference semifinal.

​Gabriel Pec, Joseph Paintsil and Dejan Joveljic each scored twice — with one goal in each half — and the LA Galaxy earned a 6-2 victory over visiting Minnesota United FC in Sunday’s Western Conference semifinal. Gabriel Pec, Joseph Paintsil and Dejan Joveljic each scored twice — with one goal in each half — and the LA Galaxy earned a 6-2 victory over visiting Minnesota United FC in Sunday’s Western Conference semifinal.   

Gabriel Pec, Joseph Paintsil and Dejan Joveljic each scored twice — with one goal in each half — and the LA Galaxy earned a 6-2 victory over visiting Minnesota United FC in Sunday’s Western Conference semifinal in Carson, California.

Paintsil also had an assist for the second-seeded Galaxy, who will host fourth-seed Seattle Sounders FC next Saturday in their first Western Conference final appearance since winning a record fifth MLS Cup in 2014.

Manager Greg Vanney’s squad is the highest remaining seed, meaning it will also host the MLS Cup final should it advance past the Sounders.

Midfielders Riqui Puig and Marco Reus each had first-half assists for LA, which has outscored opponents 15-3 over three postseason matches.

Kelvin Yeboah scored a first-half brace for sixth-seeded Minnesota, which lost for the first time in eight matches in all competitions.

Dayne St. Clair also saved a penalty kick to deny Pec — the newly minted 2024 MLS Newcomer of the Year — a hat trick. But any late hopes for a Loons comeback ended with Jefferson Díaz‘s dismissal for a second yellow card in the 82nd minute, which preceded the second goals for Paintsil and Joveljic.

LA Galaxy players celebrate after scoring a goal against Minnesota in the MLS playoffs.
LA Galaxy players celebrate after scoring a goal against Minnesota in the MLS playoffs.

USA Today Images

Even so, the Galaxy were also dominant 11-on-11 also, and from the very opening seconds when Pec’s opener gave the hosts an almost instant lead.

Puig played an exceptional outlet ball down the right to pick out the Brazilian on the run.

Pec still had a lot to do, eluding the pressure of the retreating Diaz before driving his finish past the charging St. Clair from close range.

Yeboah’s first tied the game at 1-1 five minutes later, before Joveljic’s header of Reus’ free kick service put the Galaxy up again in the 18th minute.

Paintsil added to the lead before Yeboah converted a second from the penalty spot to make it 3-2 at halftime.

But it was Pec’s sensational second that put things out of reach early in the second half.

After receiving an outlet pass from Puig in his own half, Pec used his exceptional pace and ball control to beat three Minnesota defenders down the right flank before dispatching a low finish past St. Clair and inside the far left post.

Orlando beat Atlanta United in the day’s other game — the Eastern Conference semifinal — and will play the New York Red Bulls for a spot in MLS Cup.

Information from Field Level Media was used in this recap.

 

​www.espn.com – SOCCER

Gabriel Pec, Joseph Paintsil and Dejan Joveljic each scored twice — with one goal in each half — and the LA Galaxy earned a 6-2 victory over visiting Minnesota United FC in Sunday’s Western Conference semifinal.

As Man City spiral, Liverpool open historic lead in title race​​

As Man City spiral, Liverpool open historic lead in title race​​

With Man City slumping, Liverpool look like they could put the Premier League title race to bed. That and more in this edition of Weekend Review.

​With Man City slumping, Liverpool look like they could put the Premier League title race to bed. That and more in this edition of Weekend Review. With Man City slumping, Liverpool look like they could put the Premier League title race to bed. That and more in this edition of Weekend Review.   

While Manchester City were slumping to their fifth straight defeat across all competitions, Liverpool extended their lead atop the Premier League table with a come-from-behind win over Southampton. The Reds now sit eight points ahead of the four-time defending English champions.

In Spain, Valencia returned to action following a month away in light of the devastating, deadly flooding that has overwhelmed the area. From the players on the pitch to the fans in the stands, the Mestalla was full of emotion, but the home support went home with the subtle satisfaction of witnessing Los Che‘s second win of the season.

In the Bundesliga, meanwhile, Bayern Munich picked up where they left off before the international break: keeping balls out of the back of their net. The league leaders recorded their sixth straight win, while also keeping their sixth consecutive clean sheet. An impressive feat, even if the attack was far less convincing.

What else did you miss around Europe this weekend? ESPN’s Julien Laurens, Alex Kirkland and Constantin Eckner recap all the action in this edition of ESPN’s Weekend Review.

Top takeaway: Spiralling City put Liverpool in title race driver’s seat

With Ruben Amorim debuting with Manchester United at Ipswich Town on Sunday and Manchester City’s crisis continuing to unfold with their latest defeat, the Premier League was not short of storylines this weekend, but Liverpool going eight points clear at the top of the table over Guardiola’s men is the main takeaway. Their 3-2 win at Southampton wasn’t convincing, but Mohamed Salah‘s brace, massively helped by the Saints’ defensive howlers, got them over the line after being 2-1 down.

After 12 games, eight points is a massive gap. It’s a chasm. A gulf. Only Sir Alex Ferguson’s Man United in 1993-94 had a bigger lead at this stage of the season in Premier League history.

With a mouthwatering clash between Liverpool and City next weekend at Anfield, could the title be done by early December? Chelsea, Arsenal and Brighton & Hove Albion (third, fourth and fifth in the table, respectively) are nine points behind.

It is hard to see the Reds continuing this incredible run of form (10 wins, one draw, one loss), but it is also hard to see them collapsing so badly that their rivals make up the necessary ground. This is the Premier League, though, and anything is possible.

Best match: Man City 0, Spurs 4

This was the game of the weekend across Europe, as much for the result plunging City firmly into crisis as for Spurs’ outstanding performance on the day. This encounter rarely disappoints, and it was quite extraordinary again on Saturday when the Londoners engineered a 4-0 win at the Etihad.

Best goal: Saka vs. Forest

Matheus Cunha, James Maddison and Kaoru Mitoma all could have won this week’s award, but Bukayo Saka‘s beautiful strike for Arsenal against Nottingham Forest on Saturday is a worthy winner. Cutting inside from the right onto his left foot, the England star unleashed an unstoppable strike from just inside the box.

MVP of the weekend: Matheus Cunha

What a weekend he’s enjoyed and what a player he has been in the past few weeks: six goals and three assists in his past nine Premier League appearances. Two beautiful goals and a great assist on Saturday at Fulham led Wolves to back-to-back wins. — Julien Laurens

Top takeaway: Valencia win, grieve in return to action

Valencia’s 4-2 win over Real Betis on Saturday wasn’t just about three points. It was an opportunity to remember those whose lives were lost in the region’s deadly floods last month (221 fatalities to date) and reflect on the reconstruction effort in the team’s first game back at Mestalla since the disaster.

Before kickoff, players, staff and officials gathered around a giant Senyera, the Valencian flag, covering most of the pitch. In the stands, a banner listed the names of towns and villages devastated by floodwater, where rebuilding will be ongoing for some time.

When Valencia defender César Tárrega scored the opener, he held up a shirt with the message, “We’ll get through this together.” Betis celebrated their equaliser, from an Aitor Ruibal free kick, by holding aloft a Valencian flag.

Outstanding goals from Hugo Duro and Diego López followed in an emotionally charged game. Many of Valencia’s players were personally affected by the tragedy and took to the streets in its aftermath to help. The win, only Valencia’s second of the season, took them off the bottom of the LaLiga table, but this was a day when the team’s recovery on the pitch was secondary to recovery off it.

imageplay
1:58

Valencia cruise past Real Betis with quick-fire second half goals

Relegation-battling Valencia defeat Real Betis 4-2 in a shock LaLiga win.

Best match: Celta 2, Barça 2

When Raphinha hit the post in the 77th minute — missing the chance to put Barcelona 3-0 up at Celta Vigo — only one outcome looked possible at Balaídos. How quickly things change. Five minutes later, Barcelona midfielder Marc Casadó was sent off. Two minutes after that, Alfon Gonzalez made it 2-1. And two minutes later, Hugo Álvarez scored a brilliant second, levelling at 2-2. Leaders Barça were stunned. With Celta this season, entertainment is guaranteed.

Best goal: Rodríguez vs. Valladolid

OK, so it might not have been the best goal in LaLiga this weekend, but it must have felt like it to Getafe‘s long-suffering fans. Álvaro Rodríguez‘s 70th-minute strike in their 2-0 win over Real Valladolid on Friday was Getafe’s first goal from open play all season — as a reminder, we’re now on Matchday 14, three months into the campaign. It was a smart finish, and an important goal too, helping Getafe climb clear of the bottom three.

MVP of the weekend: Federico Valverde

Real Madrid went into their game at Leganés without any fit right backs. No drama, said Valverde, who stepped into a makeshift defence and performed admirably in the role, even scoring Madrid’s second in a 3-0 away win with a trademark long-range shot. Even out of position, Valverde is still Madrid’s Mr. Reliable. — Alex Kirkland

Top takeaway: Can Bayern continue stacking up clean sheets?

Ever since Bayern Munich slipped to a 4-1 UEFA Champions League defeat to Barcelona, Vincent Kompany’s side have been on a roll. Bayern’s 3-0 home win over FC Augsburg on Friday marked their sixth consecutive win and clean sheet.

However, as they have so often in league play, Bayern had to remain patient: Despite controlling up to 80% of possession, Kompany’s side looked increasingly frustrated and bereft of ideas during the first hour inside a snow-dusted Allianz Arena. If there’s anything to criticise about Bayern’s performance, it is the fact that most of their attacking plays looked interchangeable.

The ball repeatedly moved from Joshua Kimmich to Alphonso Davies to Kingsley Coman, who was usually positioned close to the left touchline. As Coman received little to no room to force a one-on-one with Augsburg wing-back Marius Wolf, the France international retreated and the process started over again. Frequent crosses were expertly defended by Augsburg.

It was eventually a handball by Mads Pedersen, who made an unnecessary error while trying to head the ball away, that gave Bayern the chance to open the scoring from the penalty spot. Harry Kane again serenely kept his composure from 12 yards out and repeated the feat again in stoppage time after Keven Schlotterbeck had pushed the England captain inside the box.

Pessimists might say that Bayern may run out of luck at some point if teams keep defending as intensely as Augsburg and previous opponents have. In the end, though, the constant pressure through crosses and ground passes into the penalty area forces opponents into making mistakes.

Best match: Leverkusen 5, Heidenheim 2

Gone are the days when Xabi Alonso’s Leverkusen side were able to cruise to wins almost effortlessly. Instead, they have to fight for every point this season. Against Heidenheim, the Werkself were in trouble early on as they conceded twice in the opening 21 minutes before staging a remarkable comeback, eventually winning 5-2 at BayArena. Following three draws in a row, it was a much-needed victory for last season’s champions.

Best goal: Kane vs. Augsburg

Kane has set a new Bundesliga record by scoring his first 50 goals in only 43 league games. His 50th was also a beauty, with the England skipper picking up the ball in mid-air after a pinpoint cross, sending Augsburg goalkeeper Nediljko Labrovic flying as the Croatia international expected a direct header. Instead, Kane used his first touch to put the ball on his head, pushing it across the goal line while Labrović was laying on the ground.

imageplay
0:57

Harry Kane grabs his hat trick in incredible fashion for Bayern

Harry Kane takes an impressive touch in front of net to set up his own header to give Bayern Munich a 3-0 lead.

MVP of the weekend: Patrik Schick

Kane was not the only player in the Bundesliga to notch a hat trick. In light of Victor Boniface‘s thigh injury that could potentially sideline him until the winter break, Schick showed once again what an outstanding striker the Czechia international can be if he is healthy, scoring three goals against Heidenheim to secure Leverkusen their first win in the month of November. — Constantin Eckner

What else you missed this weekend

Hamburg dispense with Baumgart

Hamburg were once upon a time known as the dinosaurs of the Bundesliga because of their 55-year uninterrupted stay in Germany‘s top flight, but ever since being relegated to the 2. Bundesliga in 2018, the club have failed time and time again to secure promotion. When the club hired Steffen Baumgart in February, they were hoping that the former Cologne manager, who had been a self-confessed Hamburg fan for decades, could push them over the finish line.

Instead, Hamburg’s performances regressed.

Baumgart could neither convince with his results nor with the style with which his team were playing during the first few months of the season. While Hamburg were an attacking-minded side under former manager Tim Walter, they have played much more conservatively under Baumgart. Gathering only 20 points in the first 13 matchdays of the 2. Bundesliga season, Hamburg decided to sack Baumgart on Sunday.

Whoever gets hired in the coming days will be the seventh manager since Hamburg were relegated to Germany’s second division six-plus years ago. — Eckner

 

​www.espn.com – SOCCER

With Man City slumping, Liverpool look like they could put the Premier League title race to bed. That and more in this edition of Weekend Review.

Madrid to consider new ownership model – Pérez​​

Madrid to consider new ownership model – Pérez​​

Real Madrid president Florentino Pérez has said he’ll propose a “corporate reorganization” of the club, with members to vote on whether a change in ownership structure is necessary to protect its financial assets.

​Real Madrid president Florentino Pérez has said he’ll propose a “corporate reorganization” of the club, with members to vote on whether a change in ownership structure is necessary to protect its financial assets. Real Madrid president Florentino Pérez has said he’ll propose a “corporate reorganization” of the club, with members to vote on whether a change in ownership structure is necessary to protect its financial assets.   

 

​www.espn.com – SOCCER

Real Madrid president Florentino Pérez has said he’ll propose a “corporate reorganization” of the club, with members to vote on whether a change in ownership structure is necessary to protect its financial assets.

Madrid click after position swap for Mbappé, Vini​​

Madrid click after position swap for Mbappé, Vini​​

Carlo Ancelotti praised Kylian Mbappé’s performance after the Real Madrid forward scored from a new, left-sided role in their 3-0 LaLiga win at Leganés on Sunday.

​Carlo Ancelotti praised Kylian Mbappé’s performance after the Real Madrid forward scored from a new, left-sided role in their 3-0 LaLiga win at Leganés on Sunday. Carlo Ancelotti praised Kylian Mbappé’s performance after the Real Madrid forward scored from a new, left-sided role in their 3-0 LaLiga win at Leganés on Sunday.   

 

​www.espn.com – SOCCER

Carlo Ancelotti praised Kylian Mbappé’s performance after the Real Madrid forward scored from a new, left-sided role in their 3-0 LaLiga win at Leganés on Sunday.